The Empirics of the Labour Theory of Value: Reply to Nitzan and Bichler
Cockshott, Paul and Cottrell, Allin and Valle Baeza, Alejandro.
(2014).
Investigación Económica. Vol. LXXIII. No. 287. March. pp. 115-134.
(Article - Journal; English).
Preview |
Cover Image
cockshott_cottrell_valle_baeza_2014_the_empirics_of_the_ltv_reply_to_nitzan_and_bichler_front.jpg Download (18kB) | Preview |
Preview |
PDF (Full Text)
cockshott_cottrell_valle_baeza_2014_the_empirics_of_the_ltv_reply_to_nitzan_and_bichler.pdf Download (646kB) | Preview |
Alternative Locations
http://www.revistas.unam.mx/index.php/rie/article/view/50512
Abstract or Brief Description
The labor theory of value, originated in the classics and reformulated by Marx, has found support in numerous empirical works during the last thirty years. In many economies, sectors in monetary terms are highly correlated with them in terms of labor values. In his book Capital as Power (2009), and in a subsequent discussion online, Jonathan Nitzan and Shimshon Bichler argue that such results are invalid because the calculations do not use labor value variables but two monetary variables are correlated. Nitzan and Bichler also argue that are spurious correlations by the presence of a third variable. This article refutes both critics and consequently reinforces the empirical support for the theory of labor value.
[For the original exchange, see: "Testing the Labour Theory of Value: An Exchange" here: http://bnarchives.yorku.ca/308/]
Language
EnglishPublication Type
Article - JournalCommentary on
Testing the Labour Theory of Value: An ExchangeCockshott, Paul and Bichler, Shimshon and Nitzan, Jonathan. (2010). pp. 1-15. December. (Other; English).
Keywords
empirical verification and Marxist theory labour theory of value spurious correlationSubject
BN TheoryBN Value & Price
Depositing User
Jonathan NitzanDate Deposited
14 Jan 2017 13:42Last Modified
14 Jan 2017 14:19URL:
https://bnarchives.net/id/eprint/496Commentary/Response Threads
-
Brennan, Jordan and Cochrane, DT and Starrs, Sean
Call for Papers: "Crisis of Capital, Crisis of Theory". (deposited 06 Jun 2012)
-
Brennan, Jordan and Cochrane, DT and Starrs, Sean
"Crisis of Capital, Crisis of Theory": Conference Program and Videos. (deposited 06 Jun 2012)
-
Kourkoulakos, Stefanos and Panitch, Leo
Open Letters. (deposited 04 Nov 2010)
-
Cockshott, Paul and Bichler, Shimshon and Nitzan, Jonathan
Testing the Labour Theory of Value: An Exchange. (deposited 04 May 2014)
- Cockshott, Paul and Cottrell, Allin and Valle Baeza, Alejandro El aspecto empírico de la teoría del valor: respuesta a Nitzan y Bichler. (deposited 14 Jan 2017 13:55)
- Cockshott, Paul and Cottrell, Allin and Valle Baeza, Alejandro The Empirics of the Labour Theory of Value: Reply to Nitzan and Bichler. (deposited 14 Jan 2017 13:42) [Currently Displayed]
-
Cockshott, Paul and Bichler, Shimshon and Nitzan, Jonathan
Testing the Labour Theory of Value: An Exchange. (deposited 04 May 2014)
-
Kourkoulakos, Stefanos and Panitch, Leo
Open Letters. (deposited 04 Nov 2010)
-
Brennan, Jordan and Cochrane, DT and Starrs, Sean
"Crisis of Capital, Crisis of Theory": Conference Program and Videos. (deposited 06 Jun 2012)
Actions (login required)
View Item |